Before I start I want to say I am using MY TEAM SCOUT for all historical scouting reports.
Trade 1:
3/2/2012 (5 years, 6 months ago): Hendersonville receives RF Luis Padilla, SP Mal Windham and $5M in cash from Quebec (Now Cleveland) in exchange for SP Carlos Arevalo, MR Tomomi Sanu, SP Jack Wolochow, and CF Jesus Carrillo.
Everyone knows 2012 was a different time and era for the BSA. Quebec finished with one of the worst records in the league in 2011, losing 106 games. Hendersonville won 109 games in 2011 after being ousted by surprise Long Beach who went on to win the championship.
To Hendersonville:
RF Luis Padilla - 21 years old. 2.5/4.5* 400K
SP Mal Windham - 24 years old. 3.5/4* 400K
$5,000,000 in cash
To Quebec:
SP Carlos Arevalo - 26 years old. 4/4* 1 year, $7.25M
MR Tomomo Sanu - 25 years old. 4/4* 1 year, $5.275M
SP Jack Wolochow - 27 years old. 1/1* Unknown
RF Jesus Carrillo - 29 years old. 1.5/1.5* 1 year, $1.7M
On the surface it looks like kind of a head scratcher for Quebec. They were by far the worse team, traded the 2 younger players both under team control AND gave $5 million dollars and took on 3 players who had just hit arbitration for the first time. While Padilla wasn't what he was today, nor did scouts have him as a monster prospect he still had the most talent in the deal. But like I said on the surface isn't always what "wins" the trade or gets the better end. Arevalo was coming off a very nice season for the Hitmen while Windham got quite shelled in his rookie season, even though it seems he was called up a little early having never played past AA ball before. Sanu was also one of the better relievers in 2011.
2011 stats:
Padilla: .337/.486/.590 83 AB, 5 HR, 17 RBI. (Rookie season)
Windham: 4-23, 6.62 ERA, 1.71 WHIP, 5.81 FIP, 115K, 105BB in 178 IP.
Arevalo: 14-10, 3.62 ERA, 1.26 WHIP, 4.37 FIP, 184K, 70BB in 203.1 IP.
Sanu: 8-2, 1 save. 2.23 ERA, 1.07 WHIP, 3.61 FIP, 81K, 27BB in 72.2 IP.
Wolochow: 2-3, 5.45 ERA, 1.56 ERA, 5.63 FIP, 58K, 34BB in 74.1 IP. (with OKL & SF)
Carrillo: .231/.315/.387. 186AB, 13 2B, 4 HR, 28 RBI, 24 SB.
On the surface HEN gets the young talented rookie slugger and a talented pitcher (ratings wise) while Quebec gets a quality starting pitcher, quality reliever, a 4th OF type and throw in Wolochow. The main part of the trade is my mind is the Hitmen lost almost 19M off their bottom line before the 2012 season where they would have a payroll of 123M, one of the largest we have ever seen in the league and lose $36M for the season. The money cut was well needed.
Let's see how they fared after the trade:
Padilla: 6 years, 139 HR, 516 RBI, .308/.408/.493 (Still on HEN)
Windham: 1 year, 10-9, 5.17 ERA, 1.46 WHIP, 5.33 FIP (Traded to GRN)
Arevalo: 1 year, 4-11, 6.50 ERA, 1.64 ERA, 5.10 FIP, 98K, 54BB, in 106.2 IP (Traded back to HEN)
Sanu: 6 years, 22-10, 17 saves, 475 K, 407.5 IP, 3.27 ERA
Wolochow: 1 year, 1-2, 5.91 ERA, 1.64 ERA, 4.79 FIP, 19K, 13BB
Carrillo: 2 years, .180/.278/.281, 18 2B, 6 HR, 46 RBI, 20 SB (Released)
In the end, Padilla has been far and away the best player becoming one of the best all around bats in the league. At the time no one could have seen it coming. The only player of value ended up being Sanu for Cleveland who has been an above average reliever for the Monsters for 6 seasons now. SP Arevalo was traded back to Hendersonville 4 months later, where again Quebec gave up money...and a lot of it, $10 million in cash along with shut down bullpen arm Oliver Donahue in exchange for CF Ingo Backx and 2B Bryce Hester.
At the end of the season the trade ended up looking like this:
RF Luis Padilla
MR Oliver Donahue
SP Mal Windham
$15M in cash
MR Sanu
SP Wolochow
RF Carrillo
CF Backx
2B Hester
While Hester and Backx ended up being BSA players, one word for this debacle for Quebec was ouch.
Trade 2:
1/13/2012 (5 years, 8 months ago) Springdale (Now Greenville) receives LF Stan Hickman, SP Ron Eager, CF Augusto Grinaldo, SP Ramon Cruz, MR Jesus Salazar, C Carlos Martinez from Sacremento (Now Los Cabos) in exchange for RF Arturo Morin and MR Javier Martinez.
In 2011 both teams struggled finishing 3rd and 4th in their respective divisions. Stan Hickman had been picked with the 9th overall pick in the 2011 amateur draft and SP Eager was coming off a shaky sophomore year. At 31 years old Morin had a monster year in 2011 (and the last time he would get over over 350 AB) and had just signed a 3 year deal making an average of $12M per season. It was the simple case of trading good young players for at the time a superstar caliber player.
To Springdale:
LF Stan Hickman, 22 years old, 1/4*, MLC
SP Ron Eager, 22 years old, 4/4*, 1 year $8.5M
CF Augusto Grinaldo, 21 years old, 1.5/1.5*, MLC
SP Ramon Cruz, 27 years old, 1/1*, MLC
MR Jesus Salazar, 24 years old, 1.5/2.5*, MLC
C Carlos Martinez, 23 years old, 1/2.5*, MLC
To Sacramento:
RF Arturo Morin, 31 years old, 4.5/4.5*, 3 years, $12M per year.
MR Javier Martinez, 28 years old, 4.5/4.5*, 1 year, $5.32M
On the surface here Sacramento gets the superstar and a very good middle reliever coming off 2 very good seasons in a row, but pays the price taking on almost $10M dollars and giving up the two very valuable pieces in Hickman and Eager. Interesting at the time and 6 years later, still interesting to see how things turned out.
2011 stats:
Eager: 5-14, 5.15 ERA, 1.58 WHIP, 4.65 FIP, 131K, 63BB, 173IP
Hickman, Grinaldo, Cruz, Salazar and Martinez had yet to see the Major League Club
Morin: .303/.412/.502, 30 2B, 28 HR, 123 RBI, 140 OPS+
Martinez: 5-3, 5 saves, 3.12 ERA, 1.01 WHIP, 3.84 WHIP, 97K, 23BB, 89.1 IP
What's not to like about those numbers? A middle of the order hitter and a middle relief/set up man both at ages where they should be in their prime. Eager, 22 at the time, was probably pre maturing brought up to the majors and was taking his lumps and the rest were just young minor league players at that point.
Let's see how they fared after the trade:
Hickman: (5 years): .281/.378/.472, 80 HR, 298 RBI. (Still on team)
Eager: (4.5 years): 51-33, 4.08 ERA, 1.39 WHIP, 518K , 248 BB, 696.9 IP (Traded to LA)
Grinaldo: (1.5 years): .260/.344/.379, 436 AB, 19 2B, 11 HR, 58 RBI ( Traded to STL)
Cruz: (1 year): 1-1, 7.04 ERA, 2.05 WHIP, 5.52 FIP, 30.2 IP (Released)
Salazar: (1 year): 1-2, 7.79 ERA, 1.85 WHIP, 6.72 FIP, 17.1 IP (Claimed on Waivers by ORL)
Martinez: Never played (Traded to MAU)
Morin: (4 years): .271/.359/.435, 38 HR, 192 RBI, 1135 AB (Retired)
Martinez: (2 years): 9-7, 29 saves, 3.55 ERA, 1.22 WHIP, 160K, 46BB, 135.2IP (Traded to BAF)
What a direction this trade took! In the following 20 months after the trade, Morin missed 7+ with multiple injuries which ended up derailing his career. He never came close to matching the numbers he put up with Springdale and last played in 2015 hitting an abysmal .186 before retiring. Martinez was a quality closer for a year then was moved to middle relief before being sent to Baffin in a 9 player deal. He played 1 season there before retiring at the age of 33.
Looking at it from the view point of Sacramento, things could have been a lot worse. Hickman, while very talented, has also been ravaged with injuries, only seeing 400AB twice in his 5 year career, but still putting up solid numbers the last 3 years, is only 28 years old, and on a very team friendly contract. Eager had a solid run with Greenville before being traded to LA which netted them stud MR Hassan and current 23 year old catcher and ROY candidate Chris Moore which looks to be the real deal. Grinaldo and Martinez were both pieces in bigger deals that brought the 84's CF Perez and SP Manning. Cruz and Salazar were both basically fillers that never amounted to anything for Greenville.
This turned out to be quite the bust for Sacramento. Making the playoffs in 3 of Morin's 4 years with the team, if he could have stayed healthy who knows if LCC could have advanced further in the playoffs. Not only did it hurt by him not playing up to expectations, it seems to be the trade that keeps on giving for Greenville. Both players they traded are long retired and to show for it they have Stan Hickman in his prime, 23 year old stud Catcher Moore, 28 year old stud MR Hassan on their roster now and pieces that helped them getting Manning and Perez.
This is an example of the repercussions a trade can have when a group of young players are traded for a veteran trying to put a team over the top. If one of the players going to Springdale would have flopped and declined there were 5 more who could have made an impact. Morin's injuries and decline killed the deal for Sacramento and leaves LCC sitting here 5+ years later wondering what might have been.
GO D-BAGS